Why We Hate Small Talk (It's Not What You Think)

Last week, I was at an event and in the space of ten minutes, two different friends looked at me and said, "So, what's going on?"

Both times, my entire body tensed up and went blank. Like a full, uncomfortable freeze. If you could have seen inside my brain, it would have looked like some sort of frantic computer code searching for an answer and coming up completely empty.

So I did what I always do when I get uncomfortable with small talk. I got this look on my face that passes for a smile, said "Oh, you know…same shit, different day," paused while we both stared at each other because I gave them absolutely nothing to work with, and walked away feeling that hollow feeling when an interaction lands completely empty.

It's rarely the same shit, different day. We all know that.

But in that split second, I couldn't find a single thing to say that felt like it fit the question. So, I lied. And then I went home and thought about it way longer than a normal person would.

The Real Reason Small Talk Feels So Awful

I’ve never really understood why I hated small talk. I mean, it’s usually small talk that leads to more interesting “talk” when you find someone that you actually connect with.

But my overthinking about what had happened that day with two women who I was already connected with has led me to this hypothesis: 

We've been trained to answer "what's going on?" with outcomes. Promotions. New jobs. Exciting travel. Life milestones. The kind of thing you can deliver in ten seconds that makes it easy for the other person and for the conversation to move forward.

And if we don't have one of those ready, we do one of two things.

We perform: "OMG. Sooooo much happening, it's crazy, I'll catch you up!" 
Or we minimize: "Oh, you know. Same old."

But usually neither one is true. And for me, both options feel like a betrayal of myself.

It's Not the Small Talk. It's the Binary.

The question “What’s going on?” leaves us feeling like there has to be something going on to report about in a quick two minute exchange that you have in the lobby of a theater.  And for that, there are really only two socially acceptable answers: something polished, or nothing at all.

It doesn't leave any room for the messiness or reality of life. Which is what most of life is. 

And it definitely doesn’t leave any room for how many of us are evolving, figuring things out, leaning into something new. The slow, unglamorous, real work of shifting how you see yourself that doesn't come with a title change or a press release. The day you decided you were done tolerating something you used to grin and bear. The quiet shift that happens when you get clearer or braver or more you even when there's nothing tangible to point to yet that is impossible to package into a ten-second update. .

It's also about the day-to-day. Who our kids are becoming. How we feel in our bodies. How we're navigating the world right now – especially in the world right now. 

None of that fits in a lobby before the show starts.

So we compress it into "same old." And something dies a little in the compression. 

That's what I hate about small talk. It’s not the small talk itself but what it requires us to do with the parts of our lives that don't have a neat little bow on them yet.

We've Learned to Dismiss What We Can't Tie Up Neatly

When we can't find the headline, we don't just struggle to articulate what's going on. We start to question if we have anything to say at all. IS anything actually going on? 

We treat our own inner work as somehow less real because it doesn't have an announcement attached to it. And because we can't package it for public consumption, we dismiss it – even to ourselves. We say "same old" and in doing so, we quietly gaslight ourselves about the significance of what we're actually in the middle of.

It’s not just about the social awkwardness. It’s about the self-abandonment. 

Think about what real personal growth work actually looks like in practice.

It's the moment you catch yourself about to say yes when you mean no – and you pause to choose what’s truly best for you. It's choosing a harder conversation over a comfortable silence. It's noticing the voice in your head that tells you you're not enough and deciding, for once, not to let it make the final call. It's the slow, sometimes boring, sometimes terrifying work of learning to trust yourself.

None of that makes for great cocktail party material.

All of it changes your life. 

What's Actually Going On When You Freeze

If you've ever gone blank like I did when someone asks what's going on or if you've ever smiled and said "same old" and then walked away feeling like you’ve minimized yourself and overthinking it, here’s what I want  you to consider:

You're not bad at small talk. And you're definitely not boring. You're not "too much" or "not enough" or failing to have a life worth reporting on.

That thing you're in the middle of is probably one of the most important things that’s “going on”.  Even if you can't explain it at a cocktail party or in the lobby of a theater.

Because most of life happens in the messiness of the middle. The fact that you can't package it into a neat little update might actually be the entire point.

If this hit home, join my newsletter where I share stories, frameworks, and the occasional uncomfortable truth about personal growth, leadership, and the things that actually create change.